Criticism of Mormonism/Video/Search for the Truth DVD/The Translator

Revision as of 22:03, 18 March 2007 by MikeParker (talk | contribs) (Expand on "no plates/peepstone")
The Translator


Claim: "The Book of Mormon was not translated from the golden plates. According to his scribes the plates were usually either hidden in the woods or covered by a cloth in the room during translation. However, Joseph Smith actually did his translating by looking into a magical peepstone placed into a hat. "

The video admits that the scribes believed there were real plates. Many witnesses testified from their own experience that Joseph Smith actually had real golden plates.

Joseph's translation method was not a typical one. Most conventional translations take place with the translator reading the source document and then rendering it in a second language. Joseph, however, translated by the gift and power of God (D&C 135꞉3) — he did not know the language on the plates, so looking at the plates while translating wouldn't have done him any good. (Many LDS artists have portrayed Joseph translating by staring intently at the open plates, but this is not correct.)

In the translation process Joseph used the Urim and Thummim, and later a seerstone (what the video's producers pejoratively call a "magical peepstone"), to translate the record on the plates. We are not certain exactly how the seerstone worked, but it seems to have provided a means for him to focus and eliminate distractions so he could concentrate more fully on the translation given him by the Holy Spirit.

There are numerous Biblical examples of prophets using physical materials to divine God's will; Joseph Smith's experience fits in very well with theirs.

To read more:

Claim: "In 1826, four years before the publication of the Book of Mormon, the Joseph was arrested and charged for using his peepstone method to deceive the elderly Josiah Stowell."

The video carefully avoids describing the outcome of this legal proceeding. The video apparently wants the listener to conclude that Joseph was found guilty in court—after all, there is no shame in being charged with a crime if one is found not guilty. (And, even a false conviction is no stain on a man's character—even Jesus Himself was falsely condemned.)

But, these facts would not serve the video's purposes, so they say nothing about the outcome.

In fact, the appearance before the judge was not a trial—as demonstrated by the Reverend Wesley Walters, a prolific anti-Mormon author. Therefore, he could not be found "guilty," and no trial was held.

Despite their claims that they are trying to "Search for the Truth," the video does not tell its viewers that Josiah Stowell testified for Joseph as a defense witness and did not believe that Joseph had defrauded him at all. Stowell testified of Joseph's claims, "Do I believe it? No, it is not a matter of belief: I positively know it to be true."

The charges were brought by Stowell's family members, who seem worried that Josiah would accept Joseph's religious claims.

In fact, Stowell joined the Church founded by Joseph, and remained a faithful member to the day of his death.

Would the video's authors condemn Paul because he was brought before many courts because of religious persecution? (See Acts 23꞉6.)

Note: the video mentions the Stowell incident of 1826 in the polygamy section, and does not disclose the facts of the matter there either.

To read more:

Claim: If the Book of Mormon was translated by the gift and power of God, why have there been thousands of corrections in the Book of Mormon, many of which relate to doctrinal and historical issues?

To read more:

  • Links

Claim: "Biblical revelations never involve occult rituals or objects."

Answer #2

To read more:

  • Links

Claim: Joseph Smith was the only person who could verify that the golden plates existed.

Answer #2

To read more:

  • Links

Claim: "Initially, Joseph’s witnesses vouched for Joseph and the Golden Plates. But when pressed by the public, Joseph’s witnesses stated that they saw the golden plates through the eyes of faith and never physically saw or handled them."

Answer #2

To read more:

  • Links

Claim: The Book of Mormon contains "another gospel" as described in Galatians 1:8.

Answer #2

To read more:

  • Links

Claim: Joseph Smith's partial translation of the fraudulent Kinderhook plates shows that he was a fraud.

Answer #2

To read more:

Jump to...

Template:DVD25March2007-ToC