Array

Understanding pre-1978 statements about race: Difference between revisions
Line 21: Line 21:
{{:Source:Bruce R. McConkie:All Are Alike Unto God:Forget everything that I have said, or what President Brigham Young or President George Q. Cannon or whomsoever has said in days past that is contrary to the present revelation}}
{{:Source:Bruce R. McConkie:All Are Alike Unto God:Forget everything that I have said, or what President Brigham Young or President George Q. Cannon or whomsoever has said in days past that is contrary to the present revelation}}


==Avoid speculating without knowledge==
{{:Question: How have modern Church leaders reacted to the speculations of the past regarding the reason for the priesthood ban?}}
 
Elder Dallin H. Oaks pointed out that some leaders and members had ill-advisedly sought to provide justifications for the ban:
 
:...It's not the pattern of the Lord to give reasons. We can put reasons to commandments. When we do we're on our own. Some people put reasons to [the ban] and they turned out to be spectacularly wrong. There is a lesson in that.... The lesson I've drawn from that, I decided a long time ago that I had faith in the command and I had no faith in the reasons that had been suggested for it.
 
:...I'm referring to reasons given by general authorities and reasons elaborated upon [those reasons] by others. The whole set of reasons seemed to me to be unnecessary risk taking.
 
:...Let's [not] make the mistake that's been made in the past, here and in other areas, trying to put reasons to revelation. The reasons turn out to be man-made to a great extent. The revelations are what we sustain as the will of the Lord and that's where safety lies.<ref>{{Speech:Oaks:5 June 1988}}</ref>
 
Interviewed for a PBS special on the Church, Elder Jeffrey R. Holland said:
 
:One clear-cut position is that the folklore must never be perpetuated. ... I have to concede to my earlier colleagues. ... They, I'm sure, in their own way, were doing the best they knew to give shape to [the policy], to give context for it, to give even history to it. All I can say is however well intended the explanations were, I think almost all of them were inadequate and/or wrong. ...
 
:It probably would have been advantageous to say nothing, to say we just don't know, and, [as] with many religious matters, whatever was being done was done on the basis of faith at that time. But some explanations were given and had been given for a lot of years. ... At the very least, there should be no effort to perpetuate those efforts to explain why that doctrine existed. I think, to the extent that I know anything about it, as one of the newer and younger ones to come along, ... we simply do not know why that practice, that policy, that doctrine was in place.<ref>{{Speech:Holland:4 March 2006}}</ref>
 
Past leaders are not alive to apologize for statements that unwittingly contributed to difficulties for the faithful and stumbling blocks for those who might have otherwise have been more attracted to the overall goodness of Christ's gospel. Presumably they would join with another voice from the dust to plead for us to have charity towards them ({{s||Ether|12|35-36}}) despite their imperfections.  Rather than condemning, we ought to "give thanks unto God...that ye may learn to be more wise than we have been" ({{s||Mormon|9|31}}).
 
===Tolerance and equality commanded===
 
In 1972, Harold B. Lee cautioned:
 
:We are having come into the Church now many people of various nationalities. We in the Church must remember that we have a history of persecution, discrimination against our civil rights, and our constitutional privileges being withheld from us. These who are members of the Church, regardless of their color, their national origin, are members of the church and kingdom of God. Some of them have told us that they are being shunned. There are snide remarks. We are withdrawing ourselves from them in some cases.
 
:Now we must extend the hand of fellowship to men everywhere, and to all who are truly converted and who wish to join the Church and partake of the many rewarding opportunities to be found therein. We ask the Church members to strive to emulate the example of our Lord and Master Jesus Christ, who gave us the new commandment that we should love one another. I wish we could remember that.<ref>{{THBL1|start=384}}</ref>
 
{{:Question: How is it possible for a Church leader or prophet to have been influenced by racism, yet be consistent with the Lord not allowing prophets to lead the Church astray?}}
{{:Question: How is it possible for a Church leader or prophet to have been influenced by racism, yet be consistent with the Lord not allowing prophets to lead the Church astray?}}
{{SeeAlso|Mormonism and racial issues/Racial statements by Church leaders|l1=Racist statements by Church leaders|Official Church doctrine and statements by Church leaders|l2=Prophets are not infallible|Blacks_and_the_priesthood/Repudiated_ideas|l3=Repudiated ideas}}
{{SeeAlso|Mormonism and racial issues/Racial statements by Church leaders|l1=Racist statements by Church leaders|Official Church doctrine and statements by Church leaders|l2=Prophets are not infallible|Blacks_and_the_priesthood/Repudiated_ideas|l3=Repudiated ideas}}
</onlyinclude>
</onlyinclude>
{{CriticalSources}}
{{CriticalSources}}

Revision as of 02:57, 21 July 2016

Understanding pre-1978 statements by members and leaders of the Church

Priesthood ban
Native Americans

Template loop detected: Source:Hinckley:Ensign:May 2006:I remind you that no man who makes disparaging remarks concerning those of another race can consider himself a true disciple of Christ

Detailed Analysis

It is claimed that statements from some Church leaders or members were racist, especially before 1978. How should these statements be understood?

Understanding pre-1978 statements

See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas

Critics frequently parade justifications for the ban by past General Authorities that are considered racist by today's standards. While these have not been officially renounced, there is no obligation for current members to accept such sentiments as the "word of the Lord."


Template loop detected: Source:Bruce R. McConkie:All Are Alike Unto God:Forget everything that I have said, or what President Brigham Young or President George Q. Cannon or whomsoever has said in days past that is contrary to the present revelation

Template loop detected: Question: How have modern Church leaders reacted to the speculations of the past regarding the reason for the priesthood ban? Template loop detected: Question: How is it possible for a Church leader or prophet to have been influenced by racism, yet be consistent with the Lord not allowing prophets to lead the Church astray?

See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas


Detailed Analysis

It is claimed that statements from some Church leaders or members were racist, especially before 1978. How should these statements be understood?

Understanding pre-1978 statements

See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas

Critics frequently parade justifications for the ban by past General Authorities that are considered racist by today's standards. While these have not been officially renounced, there is no obligation for current members to accept such sentiments as the "word of the Lord."


Template loop detected: Source:Hinckley:Ensign:May 2006:I remind you that no man who makes disparaging remarks concerning those of another race can consider himself a true disciple of Christ

Detailed Analysis

It is claimed that statements from some Church leaders or members were racist, especially before 1978. How should these statements be understood?

Understanding pre-1978 statements

See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas

Critics frequently parade justifications for the ban by past General Authorities that are considered racist by today's standards. While these have not been officially renounced, there is no obligation for current members to accept such sentiments as the "word of the Lord."


Template loop detected: Source:Bruce R. McConkie:All Are Alike Unto God:Forget everything that I have said, or what President Brigham Young or President George Q. Cannon or whomsoever has said in days past that is contrary to the present revelation

Template loop detected: Question: How have modern Church leaders reacted to the speculations of the past regarding the reason for the priesthood ban? Template loop detected: Question: How is it possible for a Church leader or prophet to have been influenced by racism, yet be consistent with the Lord not allowing prophets to lead the Church astray?

See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas


Template loop detected: Source:Hinckley:Ensign:May 2006:I remind you that no man who makes disparaging remarks concerning those of another race can consider himself a true disciple of Christ

Detailed Analysis

It is claimed that statements from some Church leaders or members were racist, especially before 1978. How should these statements be understood?

Understanding pre-1978 statements

See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas

Critics frequently parade justifications for the ban by past General Authorities that are considered racist by today's standards. While these have not been officially renounced, there is no obligation for current members to accept such sentiments as the "word of the Lord."


Template loop detected: Source:Bruce R. McConkie:All Are Alike Unto God:Forget everything that I have said, or what President Brigham Young or President George Q. Cannon or whomsoever has said in days past that is contrary to the present revelation

Template loop detected: Question: How have modern Church leaders reacted to the speculations of the past regarding the reason for the priesthood ban? Template loop detected: Question: How is it possible for a Church leader or prophet to have been influenced by racism, yet be consistent with the Lord not allowing prophets to lead the Church astray?

See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas


Template loop detected: Source:Hinckley:Ensign:May 2006:I remind you that no man who makes disparaging remarks concerning those of another race can consider himself a true disciple of Christ

Detailed Analysis

It is claimed that statements from some Church leaders or members were racist, especially before 1978. How should these statements be understood?

Understanding pre-1978 statements

See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas

Critics frequently parade justifications for the ban by past General Authorities that are considered racist by today's standards. While these have not been officially renounced, there is no obligation for current members to accept such sentiments as the "word of the Lord."


Template loop detected: Source:Bruce R. McConkie:All Are Alike Unto God:Forget everything that I have said, or what President Brigham Young or President George Q. Cannon or whomsoever has said in days past that is contrary to the present revelation

Template loop detected: Question: How have modern Church leaders reacted to the speculations of the past regarding the reason for the priesthood ban? Template loop detected: Question: How is it possible for a Church leader or prophet to have been influenced by racism, yet be consistent with the Lord not allowing prophets to lead the Church astray?

See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas
See also: Racist statements by Church leaders, Prophets are not infallible, and Repudiated ideas

To see citations to the critical sources for these claims, [[../CriticalSources|click here]]

Notes




Further reading and additional sources responding to these claims

Retrieved from "http://104.237.154.152/answers/index.php?title=Understanding_pre-1978_statements_about_race&oldid=144005"