
FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
(: m) |
(: m) |
||
Line 33: | Line 33: | ||
*{{JBMS-7-1-11}} | *{{JBMS-7-1-11}} | ||
= | == == | ||
{{Topics label}} | |||
===Aha== | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Abish | |||
|subject=Abish | |||
|summary="Abish corresponds to the Hebrew name 'bš', found on a seal from pre-exilic times (prior to 587 BC) in the Hecht Museum in Haifa.19 The addition of the Hebrew letter aleph (symbolized by ' in transliteration) to the end of the name is known from other Hebrew hypocoristic names, suggesting that the name on the seal may be hypocoristic." - {{Gee Roper Tvedtnes BoM Names Label}} | |||
}} | |||
{{SummaryItem | |||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Aha | |||
|subject=Aha | |||
|summary="Aha (OW), a name of the first Pharaoh; it means "warrior" and is a common word." {{NibleyLehiDesertLabel}} | |||
*"Hugh Nibley proposed that the name was of Egyptian origin meaning "warrior". But the name is now attested in several early inscriptions as Hebrew 'h', thought by scholars to have been vocalized 'Aha' and to be a hypocoristic name based on 'ah, "brother". The longer form, rendered Ahijah in the King James Bible, is 'ahîyah(û), which means "brother of Yah (Jehovah)" or "Yah is my brother",21 which is also attested in a dozen ancient Hebrew inscriptions." - {{Gee Roper Tvedtnes BoM Names Label}} | *"Hugh Nibley proposed that the name was of Egyptian origin meaning "warrior". But the name is now attested in several early inscriptions as Hebrew 'h', thought by scholars to have been vocalized 'Aha' and to be a hypocoristic name based on 'ah, "brother". The longer form, rendered Ahijah in the King James Bible, is 'ahîyah(û), which means "brother of Yah (Jehovah)" or "Yah is my brother",21 which is also attested in a dozen ancient Hebrew inscriptions." - {{Gee Roper Tvedtnes BoM Names Label}} | ||
}} | |||
*{{JBMS-8-2-11}} | *{{JBMS-8-2-11}} | ||
{{SummaryItem | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Alma | |link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Alma | ||
Line 48: | Line 55: | ||
|summary="Alma is supposed to be a prophet of God and of Jewish ancestry in the Book of Mormon. In Hebrew Alma means a betrothed virgin maiden-hardly a fitting name for a man." - "Dr." Walter Martin, ''The Maze of Mormonism'' (Santa Ana, California: Vision House, 1978), 327. However, despite claims into the 1980s by anti-Mormon critics, the name "Alma" has been known since the 1960s as a male Hebrew name. It occurs in contexts from 2200 B.C. to the second century B.C.{{ref|roper1}} | |summary="Alma is supposed to be a prophet of God and of Jewish ancestry in the Book of Mormon. In Hebrew Alma means a betrothed virgin maiden-hardly a fitting name for a man." - "Dr." Walter Martin, ''The Maze of Mormonism'' (Santa Ana, California: Vision House, 1978), 327. However, despite claims into the 1980s by anti-Mormon critics, the name "Alma" has been known since the 1960s as a male Hebrew name. It occurs in contexts from 2200 B.C. to the second century B.C.{{ref|roper1}} | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{SummaryItem | |||
= | |link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Ammon | ||
|subject=Ammon | |||
|summary="Ammon (Amon, Amun) (OW), the commonest name in the Egyptian Empire: the great universal God of the Empire."{{NibleyLehiDesertLabel}} | |||
= | }} | ||
{{SummaryItem | |||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Ammonihah | |||
|subject=Ammonihah | |||
|summary="Ammoni-hah (BM), name of a country and city. [compare with] Ammuni-ra (OW), prince of Beyrut under Egyptian rule. The above might stand the same relationship to this name as Khamuni-ra (OW), Amarna personal name, perhaps equivalent of Ammuni-ra."{{NibleyLehiDesertLabel}} "The name is attested on two Hebrew seals, one known to date to the seventh century BC, in the forms ‘mnyhw and ‘mnwyhw." - {{Gee Roper Tvedtnes BoM Names Label}} | |||
}} | |||
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see: | For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see: | ||
* {{JBMRS-18-1-6}} <!--Hoskisson--> | * {{JBMRS-18-1-6}} <!--Hoskisson--> | ||
= | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Chemish | |||
|subject=Chemish | |||
= | |summary="His name is apparently related to that of the Ammonite god Chemosh, spelled Kmš in prevocalic Hebrew and Ammonite (related languages). A number of names containing the element Kmš are known, in which it is clear that the divine name was meant.33 Also known is a seal currently in the Israel Museum that has Kmš as the name of a man or woman." - {{Gee Roper Tvedtnes BoM Names Label}} | ||
}} | |||
{{SummaryItem | |||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Com | |||
|subject=Com | |||
|summary= | |||
}} | |||
* Criticism: {{CriticalWork:Sunderland:Mormonism:10 February 1838}} | * Criticism: {{CriticalWork:Sunderland:Mormonism:10 February 1838}} | ||
{{nw}} | {{nw}} | ||
= | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Korihor | |||
|subject=Corihor | |||
|summary= | |||
}} | |||
''See:''[[Book_of_Mormon_anachronisms:Names#Korihor|Korihor]] | ''See:''[[Book_of_Mormon_anachronisms:Names#Korihor|Korihor]] | ||
= | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Cumenihah | |||
|subject=Cumenihah | |||
|summary= | |||
}} | |||
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see: | For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see: | ||
* {{JBMRS-18-1-6}} <!--Hoskisson--> | * {{JBMRS-18-1-6}} <!--Hoskisson--> | ||
= | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Cumorah | |||
|subject=Cumorah | |||
|summary= | |||
}} | |||
* {{JBMS-6-2-15}} | * {{JBMS-6-2-15}} | ||
= | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Hagoth | |||
|subject=Hagoth | |||
= | |summary="One Book of Mormon critic argued that Joseph Smith derived the name Hagoth from the name of the biblical prophet Haggai. Indeed, the names may be related, but a closer parallel is the biblical Haggith (see {{b|2|Samuel|3|4}}; {{b|1|Kings|1|5}}, etc.), which may have been vocalized Hagoth anciently. All three names derive from a root referring to a pilgrimage to attend religious festivals. The name Hagoth is attested in the form Hgt on an Ammonite seal inscribed sometime in the eighth through the sixth centuries BC36 (The Ammonites, neighbors of the Israelites and descendants of Abraham's nephew Lot, wrote and spoke the same language as the Israelites.)" - {{Gee Roper Tvedtnes BoM Names Label}} | ||
}} | |||
{{SummaryItem | |||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Helaman | |||
= | |subject=Helaman | ||
|summary="Helaman (BM), great Nephite prophet. [compare with] Her-amon (OW), "in the presence of Amon," as in the Egyptian proper name Heri-i-her-imn. Semitic "l" is always written "r" in Egyptian, which has no "l." Conversely, the Egyptian "r" is often written "l" in Semitic languages.{{NibleyLehiDesertLabel}} | |||
}} | |||
{{SummaryItem | |||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Hem | |||
= | |subject=Hem | ||
|summary="Hem (BM), brother of the earlier Ammon." "Hem (OW), means "servant," specifically of Ammon, as in the title Hem tp n 'Imn, "chief servant of Ammon" held by the high priest of Thebes."{{NibleyLehiDesertLabel}} | |||
}} | |||
{{SummaryItem | |||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Himni | |||
|subject=Himni | |||
= | |summary="Himni (BM), a son of King Mosiah. Hmn (OW), a name of the Egyptian hawk-god, symbol of the emperor."{{NibleyLehiDesertLabel}} "...the name Himni is clearly Hebrew and is represented by the unvocalized form, Hmn on two Israelite seals. The first, from the eighth century BC, was found at Megiddo in the Jezreel Valley. The other is from the first half of the seventh century BC." - {{Gee Roper Tvedtnes BoM Names Label}} | ||
}} | |||
{{SummaryItem | |||
= | |link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Isabel | ||
|subject=Isabel | |||
|summary="Isabel was a harlot in the land of Siron, on the border between the Lamanites and the Zoramites (see {{s||Alma|39|3}}). LDS scholars have generally assumed that the name is identical to that of the Old Testament Jezebel, the Hebrew form of which was 'ÃŽzebel, and this is probably correct. But the spelling Yzbl is now attested on a seal in the Israel Museum in Jerusalem that is thought to be Phoenician in origin." - {{Gee Roper Tvedtnes BoM Names Label}} | |||
}} | |||
{{SummaryItem | |||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Irreantum | |||
|subject=Irreantum | |||
|summary= | |||
}} | |||
{{MaxwellInstituteBar | {{MaxwellInstituteBar | ||
|link=http://publications.maxwellinstitute.byu.edu/fullscreen/?pub=1406&index=15 | |link=http://publications.maxwellinstitute.byu.edu/fullscreen/?pub=1406&index=15 | ||
Line 119: | Line 149: | ||
''See'': [[Book_of_Mormon_anachronisms:Names#Less well supported examples|below]]. | ''See'': [[Book_of_Mormon_anachronisms:Names#Less well supported examples|below]]. | ||
= | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Jarrom | |||
|subject=Jarrom | |||
|summary="One might wish to compare Jarom with the biblical name Jehoram, which is found twenty-one times in the Bible, while its hypocoristic form Joram occurs twenty-four times. But several Hebrew inscriptions bear the name Yrm, which scholars consider to be the hypocoristic form of Yrmyh(w), Jeremiah, whose name means "Yah (Jehovah) exalts." Yrm is found in four Hebrew inscriptions, including a seal of the seventh century BC, found in Egypt, and three items from the time of Lehi: a jug inscription from Tel esh-Shari‘ah, and an ostracon and bulla in the Moussaieff collection." - {{Gee Roper Tvedtnes BoM Names Label}} | |||
}} | |||
===Jershon=== | ===Jershon=== | ||
{{SummaryItem | |||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Jershon | |||
|subject=Jershon | |||
|summary= | |||
}} | |||
{{PerspectivesBar | {{PerspectivesBar | ||
|link=http://www.fairmormon.org/perspectives/fair-conferences/2001-fair-conference/2001-right-on-target-boomerang-hits-and-the-book-of-mormon | |link=http://www.fairmormon.org/perspectives/fair-conferences/2001-fair-conference/2001-right-on-target-boomerang-hits-and-the-book-of-mormon | ||
Line 145: | Line 182: | ||
}} | }} | ||
= | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Names/Josh | |||
|subject=Josh | |||
|summary="Josh was the name of a city destroyed at the time of Christ's crucifixion (see {{s|3|Nephi|9|10}}) and of a Nephite military leader who died in the great battle at Cumorah (see {{s||Mormon|6|14}}). Critics have suggested that this is merely the American diminutive for the name Joshua. But a number of Hebrew inscriptions bear the name Y'š, probably vocalized Yô'š, which Israeli scholars have acknowledged to be hypocoristic for the biblical name Y'šyhw, Josiah, in whose reign Jeremiah began his prophetic mission (see Jeremiah 1:2; 27:1).43 The name appears in three of the Lachish letters (2, 3, and 6) from the time of Lehi.44 It is also the name of four persons named in the fifth-century BC Jewish Aramaic papyri from Elephantine, Egypt. Four of the bullae found near Tel Beit Mirsim and dating from ca. 600 BC bear the name Y'š. Three of them were made from the same seal. | |||
}} | |||
* Criticism: {{CriticalWork:Sunderland:Mormonism:10 February 1838}} | |||
== == | == == |
Answers portal |
Book of Mormon |
![]() |
![]() |
---|
General information: Book of Mormon & Bible: Criticisms: |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
It is claimed that some Book of Mormon names are used improperly or in an inappropriate context.
Examples include:
To see citations to the critical sources for these claims, click here
Many Book of Mormon names are not found in the Bible, and were unknown to Joseph Smith. Yet, these names have meaning in ancient languages and/or have been found as actual names from ancient history. These "hits" provide additional evidence that the Book of Mormon is indeed an ancient record.
Hugh Nibley did considerable work on Book of Mormon names. References to his work will be marked as follows to avoid multiple, repetitive footnotes:
Others:
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see:
See:Korihor
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see:
The greatest challenge for persons interested in the meanings of proper names in the Book of Mormon has to do with those names whose meanings we already know, such as Rameumptom, "the holy stand" (Alma 31:21); Rabbanah, "powerful or great king" (Alma 18:13); and Irreantum,1 "many waters" (1 Nephi 17:5). Six such names with their translations appear in the Book of Mormon.2 Determining their meanings etymologically is a challenge because any attempt to trace their ancient roots has to come to results that match the translations given in the Book of Mormon and do so without many complicated steps. After all, the ancient people who conferred these names most likely did so with ease, without convoluted linguistic manipulation. On the other hand, names that are not accompanied by a translation are open to any number of possible interpretations because the text does not require a specific outcome.
This study of the name Irreantum has been a double challenge, for the reason just given and also because it was necessary to delve into languages outside the Northwest Semitic language group. For the latter reason, I asked two of my colleagues at Brigham Young University, Brian M. Hauglid and John Gee, whose specialties are respectively Arabic and Egyptian, to contribute to this article.
See: below.
The Book of Mormon name Jershon can be traced to a Hebrew root meaning “to inherit.” In the Book of Mormon we read “Behold, we will give up the land of Jershon, which is on the east by the sea…and this land of Jershon is the land which we will give unto our brethren for an inheritance” (Alma 27:22).
When the Lamanites converted by the sons of Mosiah fled their homeland to escape persecution, the Nephites allowed them to settle in the land of Jershon. The name, though not found in the Bible, has an authentic Hebrew origin, the root *YRŠ,13 meaning "to inherit," with the suffix -ôn that denotes place-names.14 Wilhelm Borée, in his outstanding study, Die alten Ortsnamen Palästinas (The Ancient Place Names of Palestine), cites fully 84 ancient Canaanite place names with the ending - ôn in biblical and extrabiblical sources (Egyptian and Mesopotamian writings, the El-Amarna letters, ostraca), including Ayyalon (Elon) (Joshua 19:42, 43), Eltekon (Joshua 15:58), Ashkelon (Judges 1:18), Gibeon (Joshua 9:3), Gibbethon (Joshua 19:44), Dishon (Genesis 36:21), Ziphron (Numbers 34:9), Helbon (Ezekiel 27:18), Holon (Joshua 21:15), Hammon (Joshua 19:28), Hebron (Joshua 10:36), Hannathon (Joshua 19:14), Dibon (Numbers 21:30), and Heshbon (Numbers 21:30).15
It is in this light that we should understand the words in Alma 27:22 ("and this land Jershon is the land which we will give unto our brethren for an inheritance"), Alma 27:24 ("that they may inherit the land Jershon"), and Alma 35:14 ("they have lands for their inheritance in the land of Jershon").
This study considers the Book of Mormon personal names Josh, Nahom, and Alma as test cases for the Book of Mormon as an historically authentic ancient document.
Compare: Paanchi
Wrote Hugh Nibley of this Old World name:
Lehi or Mulek's group would have then known—or even contained—people named "Lachoneus," a proper Greek name of the proper sort in the proper timeframe.
Compare: Timothy
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see:
One view:
"Critic Walter Prince suggested an unusual derivation for the name, writing, "Just lisp the sibilant and you have the entire word 'Mason' and almost the entire word "Masonic" in both of these appellations."48 Prince would have done better to look to the Bible.
The fact that Mathoni is hypocoristic for Mathonihah reinforces the idea that the element -ihah is the Nephite form of the divine name (see Ammonihah, above). This being the case, Mathonihah would correspond to KJV Mattaniah (Hebrew Mtnyhw), the birth-name of Zedekiah (see 2 Kings 24:17), who was king of Judah when Lehi left Jerusalem (see 1 Nephi 1:4). Several other biblical personalities bore this name. We can then compare Mathoni to biblical Mattan, the name of two different men, one of whom was a contemporary of Lehi and Jeremiah (see Jeremiah 38:1). (Note that the Hebrew letter tav is sometimes transliterated t in the Bible, as in these names, and sometimes th, as in Methuselah.)
Hugh Nibley was the first to suggest that the Book of Mormon name Mathonihah corresponded to biblical Mattaniah, while its biform Mathoni (see 3 Nephi 19:4) corresponded to biblical Mattan. He further noted that both names are found in the Elephantine Papyri and that the longer form occurs in the Lachish letters, written just a few years after Lehi left Jerusalem. - [Gee Roper Tvedtnes 2000]
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see:
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see:
Muloki was one of the men who accompanied the sons of Mosiah on their mission to the Lamanites (see Alma 20:2; 21:11). His name suggests that he may have been a Mulekite. Also from the same root are names such as Mulek and Melek, which is the Hebrew word meaning "king". Mulek is hypocoristic for Hebrew Mlkyh(w) (KJV Melchiah and Malchiah), which is attested both in the Bible (see 1 Chronicles 6:40; Ezra 10:25, 3; Nehemiah 3:14, 31; 8:4; 11:12; Jeremiah 21:1; 38:1, 6) and in numerous ancient inscriptions, most of them from the time of Lehi. Indeed, it has been suggested that one of the men bearing this name is the Mulek of the Book of Mormon. He is called "Malchiah the son of Hammelech," which means "Malchiah, son of the king" (see Jeremiah 38:6).
Muloki corresponds to the name Mlky on a bulla found in the City of David (Jerusalem) and dating from the time of Lehi. - [Gee Roper Tvedtnes 2000]
This study considers the Book of Mormon personal names Josh, Nahom, and Alma as test cases for the Book of Mormon as an historically authentic ancient document.
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see:
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see:
Compare: Korihor
Gee, Roper, and Tvedtnes:
Sam, brother of Nephi, came to the New World with his father Lehi and family (see 1 Nephi 2:5; 2 Nephi 5:6; Alma 3:6). Critics have suggested that Joseph Smith simply used the common English diminutive of Samuel. What these critics failed to realize is that the name Samuel, which appears in the English Bible, is from the Hebrew name (Å mû'el) comprised of two elements, Shem ("name") + El ("God").
The name Sam is attested on a bronze ringmounted seal dated to the seventh century BC60 While others have read this name as Shem, in paleo- Hebrew there is no distinction in writing between s and š (the latter written sh in English). (It is the same letter used at the beginning of the name Sariah.) Various dialects of Hebrew pronounced this letter in different ways anciently. From the story in Judges 12:6, we find that some of the tribe of Joseph pronounced it s instead of š, reminding us that Lehi was a descendant of Joseph (see 1 Nephi 5:14). - [Gee Roper Tvedtnes 2000]
Critics have argued that "Timothy" is an unlikely Nephite name, since it is of Greek origin.
Hugh Nibley pointed out:
Compare: Lachoneus
It would thus not be at all surprising for Lehites or Mulekites to be familiar with the name "Timothy" (or a derivative), or even for a "Timothy" to have accompanied Mulek's party of immigrants.
For remarks on the "-ihah" ending likely not reflecting the divine name of God (Yahweh or Jehovah), see:
Linguistics is a complex subject, and it is all too common for zealous but mistaken defenders of the Church to use parallels in names or language which cannot be sustained. Since most Church members have no training in ancient American languages, evaluating such claims can be difficult.
Mesoamerican scholars consulted by FAIR have recommended that the following sources, while superficially persuasive, should be used with caution (if at all):
These comments are not intended to disparage the individuals involved, but to encourage rigor and restraint in claims made. As Elder Dallin H. Oaks cautioned, "When attacked by error, truth is better served by silence than by a bad argument."[8]
<videoflash>pDqeaU0N-tg</videoflash>
== Notes ==
FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
We are a volunteer organization. We invite you to give back.
Donate Now