FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Array
Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink: Difference between revisions
(→Other Translation Related Topics: format) |
(mod) |
||
| Line 163: | Line 163: | ||
|summary=({{antilink|http://mormonthink.com/jst.htm}}) MormonThink concludes that the "Joseph Smith Translation" of the Bible needs to be added to the "Book of Abraham facsimiles and papyri, the Anthon Manuscript, the Kinderhook Plates, Joseph Smith’s Book of Egyptian Alphabet and Grammar and the Greek Psalter" as demonstrations that Joseph lacked the ability to translate anything. | |summary=({{antilink|http://mormonthink.com/jst.htm}}) MormonThink concludes that the "Joseph Smith Translation" of the Bible needs to be added to the "Book of Abraham facsimiles and papyri, the Anthon Manuscript, the Kinderhook Plates, Joseph Smith’s Book of Egyptian Alphabet and Grammar and the Greek Psalter" as demonstrations that Joseph lacked the ability to translate anything. | ||
}} | }} | ||
====Controversial Past Practices===== | |||
====Polygamy==== | ====="Polygamy"===== | ||
{{SummaryItem | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink/Polygamy | |link=Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink/Polygamy | ||
| Line 170: | Line 170: | ||
|summary=({{antilink|http://mormonthink.com/joseph-smith-polygamy.htm}}) MormonThink concludes in this article that we should believe that Oliver Cowdery's claim that Joseph had an affair should be given credence because Oliver was also a Book of Mormon witness. | |summary=({{antilink|http://mormonthink.com/joseph-smith-polygamy.htm}}) MormonThink concludes in this article that we should believe that Oliver Cowdery's claim that Joseph had an affair should be given credence because Oliver was also a Book of Mormon witness. | ||
}} | }} | ||
====Blacks and the priesthood==== | ====="Blacks and the priesthood"===== | ||
{{SummaryItem | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=|link=Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink/Blacks and the Priesthood | |link=|link=Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink/Blacks and the Priesthood | ||
| Line 176: | Line 176: | ||
|summary=({{antilink|http://www.mormonthink.com/blackweb.htm}}) This MormonThink article concludes that President Kimball did not actually receive a revelation ending the priesthood ban. | |summary=({{antilink|http://www.mormonthink.com/blackweb.htm}}) This MormonThink article concludes that President Kimball did not actually receive a revelation ending the priesthood ban. | ||
}} | }} | ||
====Temple Related Topics==== | |||
====="The Temple"===== | |||
====The Temple==== | |||
{{parabreak}} | {{parabreak}} | ||
{{SummaryItem | {{SummaryItem | ||
| Line 190: | Line 185: | ||
}} | }} | ||
====Church integrity==== | ====Church integrity==== | ||
====="Lying for the Lord"===== | |||
{{SummaryItem | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink/Lying for the Lord | |link=Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink/Lying for the Lord | ||
| Line 195: | Line 191: | ||
|summary=({{antilink|http://www.mormonthink.com/lying.htm}}) MormonThink concludes that lying is "standard operating procedure for Church leaders" from Joseph Smith's time to the present, and that pretty much every thing that the Church does is somehow related to deception (FAIR note: this is a standard position taken by many ex-Mormons after their disaffection with the Church). | |summary=({{antilink|http://www.mormonthink.com/lying.htm}}) MormonThink concludes that lying is "standard operating procedure for Church leaders" from Joseph Smith's time to the present, and that pretty much every thing that the Church does is somehow related to deception (FAIR note: this is a standard position taken by many ex-Mormons after their disaffection with the Church). | ||
}} | }} | ||
====Tithing==== | ====="Tithing"===== | ||
{{SummaryItem | {{SummaryItem | ||
|link=Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink/Tithing | |link=Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink/Tithing | ||
|subject=A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Tithing" | |subject=A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Tithing" | ||
|summary=({{antilink|http://www.mormonthink.com/tithing.htm}}) This MormonThink article concludes that the Church spends little on humanitarian aid, and that members ought to send their contributions elsewhere. | |summary=({{antilink|http://www.mormonthink.com/tithing.htm}}) This MormonThink article concludes that the Church spends little on humanitarian aid, and that members ought to send their contributions elsewhere. | ||
}} | |||
====Other Topics==== | |||
====="Conflicts with Science"===== | |||
{{SummaryItem | |||
|link=Criticism of Mormonism/Websites/MormonThink/Conflicts with Science | |||
|subject=A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Conflicts with Science" | |||
|summary=({{antilink|http://www.mormonthink.com/scienceweb.htm}}) This MormonThink article concludes that acceptance of scientific facts and a belief in God are incompatible. | |||
}} | }} | ||
<!-- | <!-- | ||
Revision as of 20:52, 6 December 2012
A FAIR Analysis of: MormonThink A work by author: Anonymous
|
| High Level Summary | |
|---|---|
| Title | MormonThink.com |
| Type | Website |
| Author(s) | Anonymous |
| Affiliation | "Active" members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints; Ex-Mormons active on the Recovery from Mormonism message board. |
| Accuracy | Conclusions drawn are predominantly negative toward the truth claims of the Church. |
| Temple content | NOTE: Extremely detailed temple content is sometimes present on the site. |
A FAIR Analysis of the critical website MormonThink
I fantasize about a full-blown faith-destroying session. In real life, I did put the bishop in his place over polygamy. He kept saying I was wrong about Joseph having other wives and being illegal and such. I proved him wrong and he ate crow.
—MormonThink's founding editor, Feb. 21, 2012 [1]
So that is one of the reasons I remain in the church. It gives me greater credibility when I speak about my own religion instead of it being my former religion. We all know as soon as I leave it, I am labeled as someone who left because of morality, tithing or some other issue rather than the historical problems of the church....By subtly mentioning things in meetings I may raise some doubts...
—MormonThink's founding editor, Jan, 2012 [2]
If you would like to help further, please excommunicate the next editor at MormonThink. Have leaders of the [Strengthening Church Members Committee] stalk us. Even better, send in the Danites please. That should propel MormonThink popularity into orbit around Kolob.
—MormonThink managing editor David Twede, after emailing his resignation to the Church, October 19, 2012. [3]
Overview
The website mormonthink.com is designed to lead Church members into questioning their beliefs in a non-threatening manner by claiming to be "objective" and "balanced." The site claims to be run by active members of the Church. In reality, however, they are "active" only in the sense that some of them still occasionally attend Church—they do not accept the Church's truth claims, and they have no interest in strengthening belief. Instead, the site portrays Church leaders as liars, Joseph Smith as a fraud and con-man, and the Church as "an oppressive empire building corporation." The site includes links to FAIR as a way of demonstrating their claimed "balance."
Each page on MormonThink.com typically includes quotes from Church sources, large amounts of block text copied from websites critical of the Church, a few references to LDS apolgetics that are followed by mocking refutations by critics, an "Ending summary by critics," and an "Our Thoughts" section, which generally agrees with the critics. The bottom of each page contains links to critical sites, believers sites and to some sites which they consider neutral.
MormonThink has had a series of managing editors, all of whom retained membership in the Church during their tenure while simultaneously mocking the Church's truth claims in online ex-Mormon forums. The transfer of the editorial position appears to be triggered by the resignation from the Church of the previous editor. The founding editor, who remains anonymous, resigned in 2012 in order to avoid discipline after the Church apparently identified him. In his parting letter to his Stake President (posted on the MormonThink website), he states,
You said that [MormonThink] is 'anti-Mormon, anti-Joseph Smith and anti-LDS Leadership'. However, you never said it wasn’t true.[4]
The most publicly well known managing editor was David Twede. Shortly after taking over the site, Twede was approached by local Church leaders and scheduled for discipline. After creating a media spectacle regarding his scheduled discipline, Twede resigned publicly during an appearance at the open mike session at the 2012 Ex-Mormon Foundation Conference in Salt Lake City. After emailing his resignation letter, Twede publicly challenged the Church,
If you’d like to help further, please, by all means, excommunicate the next editor at MormonThink. Have leaders of the Strengthening Members Committee stalk us. Even better, send in the Danites, please, please. That should propel MormonThink popularity into orbit around Kolob. [5]
MormonThink's directors consider Church attempts to impose discipline on their editors as a beneficial way of increasing traffic and visibility of the website, thus making Church membership more aware of its existence.
Media efforts in 2012 by Mormonthink managing editor David Twede
Summary: David Twede went to the media in September 2012 after claiming that the Church was attempting to discipline him for his online writings about Mitt Romney posted both on his blog and on MormonThink. Details regarding this effort may be found in the sub-articles linked here.The specific content of the MormonThink website is addressed in the articles listed below
Click on the links for detailed point-by-point discussion of specific content.
General topics
Overview of the MormonThink website
Summary: The web site MormonThink.com claims to be operated by active members of the Church with an interest in objectively presenting the "truth" about Mormonism. In general, the conclusions reached by the site reflect negatively on the Church. The best explanation of the purpose of the website is offered the words of its own webmaster, and by the testimonials of ex-Mormons who claim that the site caused them to lose belief and leave the Church.Response to MormonThink's list of 25 items that would allegedly "make the Church true"
Summary: ( http://www.mormonthink.com/endpage.htm) According to MormonThink.com, if the Church actually contained God's truth and authority, "we would expect the following things to have happened in this way." The following is a list of issues presented by the website followed by FAIR's response. Most items on the list are standard anti-Mormon fare, issues FAIR believes have been "asked and answered" many times. Nearly all points appeal to some type of intellectual or religious fundamentalism.The Book of Mormon
"Joseph Running with the Plates"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Joseph Running with the Plates"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/runningweb.htm) This MormonThink article concludes that Joseph could not have run with the gold plates because he had a limp from his leg operation as a child, and that his story of running with the plates is a "tall tale.""Translation of the Book of Mormon"
MormonThink's "Translation of the Book of Mormon" source quotes without critical or apologetic commentary
Summary: This is the "no spin" version. We provide all of the complete primary and secondary source quotes without the "Critic's comment," "Apologetic rebuttal" or "Our Thoughts" sections.A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Translation of the Book of Mormon"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/transbomweb.htm) This MormonThink article concludes that "Most of us could probably accept the translation method more easily if we had always been taught about the 'stone in the hat' method but we have a hard time accepting it now knowing that the leaders know about it but all the Church manuals, paintings, Church magazines, Church website, Church movies, missionary discussions, etc. purposely show a very different method.""Could Joseph Smith have written the Book of Mormon"
MormonThink's "Could Joseph Smith have written the Book of Mormon" source quotes without critical or apologetic commentary
Summary: This is the "no spin" version. We provide all of the complete primary and secondary source quotes without the "Critic's comment," "Apologetic rebuttal" or "Our Thoughts" sections.A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Could Joseph Smith have written the Book of Mormon?"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/josephweb.htm) This MormonThink article concludes that "The Nephites and Lamanites were primitive peoples. Joseph Smith would have been considered a scholar compared to any Indians that lived 2,000 years ago. Yet we don't question that the ancient Indians wrote the original Book of Mormon, but we totally reject the idea that a 19th century man couldn't have done the same thing. That makes reason stare." (FAIR note: we find this conclusion somewhat insulting to Native Americans)"The Lost 116 Pages of the Book of Mormon"
MormonThink's "The Lost 116 Pages of the Book of Mormon" source quotes without critical or apologetic commentary
Summary: This is the "no spin" version. We provide all of the complete primary and secondary source quotes without the "Critic's comment," "Apologetic rebuttal" or "Our Thoughts" sections.A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "The Lost 116 Pages of the Book of Mormon"
Summary: ( http://www.mormonthink.com/lost116web.htm) This MormonThink article draws the following conclusion: "There's an episode of the cartoon South Park called "All About the Mormons". In the episode, a faithful LDS family tells the story of the lost 116 pages to a neighbor boy they are trying to convert. They tell this story as proof that Joseph Smith was telling the truth and Mormonism is true. Perhaps the most telling comment we've ever heard about the lost 116 pages debacle comes from the neighborhood boy, who, after hearing the story of the lost 116 pages, exclaims "'Wait, Mormons actually know this story and they still believe Joseph Smith was a Prophet?'" (FAIR note: As believing Latter-day Saints, we find this conclusion insulting.)"Book of Mormon Difficulties"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Book of Mormon Difficulties" (Part 1)
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/book-of-mormon-problems.htm) This MormonThink article concludes that "While we cannot accept the Book of Mormon story as literally historical; we can, in a sense, accept the book as a somewhat symbolic embodiment of 'the American story' - the creation of a unique but "familiar" vision of manifest destiny, wars waged to protect the "liberties" of patriots, democracies created to secure the sanctity of these liberties, and the overarching struggle of good and evil - all roughly woven together within the framework of an American Christian apocalypse."A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Book of Mormon Difficulties" (Part 2)
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/book-of-mormon-problems.htm)"The Witnesses"
MormonThink's "The Witnesses" source quotes without critical or apologetic commentary
Summary: This is the "no spin" version. We provide all of the complete primary and secondary source quotes without the "Critic's comment," "Apologetic rebuttal" or "Our Thoughts" sections.A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "The Witnesses"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/witnessesweb.htm) MormonThink concludes that the witnesses may have only seen the plates in a vision, rather than with their own eyes.Visions
"The First Vision"
MormonThink's "The First Vision" source quotes without critical or apologetic commentary
Summary: This is the "no spin" version. We provide all of the complete primary and secondary source quotes without the "Critic's comment," "Apologetic rebuttal" or "Our Thoughts" sections.A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "The First Vision"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/firstvisionweb.htm) MormonThink concludes that the story of the First Vision "is very simplified and perhaps not likely to be what really happened when you consider all the evidence contradicting the official account of the First Vision that we were all taught in Sunday School.""Moroni's Visitation"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Moroni's Visitation"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/moroniweb.htm) This MormonThink article concludes that Moroni's visit was likely a "dream or hallucination."Other Translation Related Topics
"The Kinderhook Plates"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "The Kinderhook Plates"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/kinderhookweb.htm) MormonThink, in this case, continues to quote old apologetics regarding the Kinderhook plates and actually refers the uncovering of new data clarifying the event as an apologetic "ploy." We note that the most recent new data on this subject presented by Don Bradley obliterates the old apologetic arguments. The new data suggests that Joseph attempted to translate a character on the Kinderhook Plates manually by matching it to a similar character in the Grammar and Alphabet of the Egyptian Language (which, by the way, actually has nothing to do with actual Egyptian). The "translation" recorded by William Clayton matched the explanation given for the character in the GAEL."The Greek Psalter Translation"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page" The Greek Psalter Translation"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/greekweb.htm) This MormonThink article concludes that because of the "Book of Abraham, Kinderhook Plates and the Joseph Smith translation of the Bible," that the Greek Psalter story "further damages Joseph's claims to be a true seer.""Joseph's Translation of the Bible"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Joseph's Translation of the Bible"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/jst.htm) MormonThink concludes that the "Joseph Smith Translation" of the Bible needs to be added to the "Book of Abraham facsimiles and papyri, the Anthon Manuscript, the Kinderhook Plates, Joseph Smith’s Book of Egyptian Alphabet and Grammar and the Greek Psalter" as demonstrations that Joseph lacked the ability to translate anything.Controversial Past Practices=
"Polygamy"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Polygamy"
Summary: ( http://mormonthink.com/joseph-smith-polygamy.htm) MormonThink concludes in this article that we should believe that Oliver Cowdery's claim that Joseph had an affair should be given credence because Oliver was also a Book of Mormon witness."Blacks and the priesthood"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Blacks and the Priesthood"
Summary: ( http://www.mormonthink.com/blackweb.htm) This MormonThink article concludes that President Kimball did not actually receive a revelation ending the priesthood ban.Temple Related Topics
"The Temple"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Temple"
Summary: MormonThink originally removed this page containing detailed information about the temple, not because it was offensive to Latter-day Saints, but only because it was driving ex-Mormons' believing spouses away from examining their critical website. The content has been removed and added back several times. FAIR responds to a number of issues raised which are not related to the explicit temple content that the site sometimes hosts.Church integrity
"Lying for the Lord"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Lying for the Lord"
Summary: ( http://www.mormonthink.com/lying.htm) MormonThink concludes that lying is "standard operating procedure for Church leaders" from Joseph Smith's time to the present, and that pretty much every thing that the Church does is somehow related to deception (FAIR note: this is a standard position taken by many ex-Mormons after their disaffection with the Church)."Tithing"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Tithing"
Summary: ( http://www.mormonthink.com/tithing.htm) This MormonThink article concludes that the Church spends little on humanitarian aid, and that members ought to send their contributions elsewhere.Other Topics
"Conflicts with Science"
A FAIR Analysis of MormonThink page "Conflicts with Science"
Summary: ( http://www.mormonthink.com/scienceweb.htm) This MormonThink article concludes that acceptance of scientific facts and a belief in God are incompatible.== Notes ==
- [note] Comment by MormonThink's founding editor, posting as "SpongeBob SquareGarments" on the ex-Mormon message board Recovery from Mormonism, Feb. 21, 2012
- [note] Comment posted by MormonThink's founding editor on thread "I am the webmaster of MormonThink.com AMA", ex-Mormon reddit, Jan. 2012
- [note] Comment by former MormonThink managing editor David Twede, immediately after emailing his resignation letter to the Church during the open mike session at the Exmormon Foundation 2012 Conference, October 19, 2012.
- [note] Former MormonThink managing editor in a letter to his Stake President prior to his resignation in order to avoid Church discipline. Posted as "MormonThink Founder Resignation" on mormonthink.com
- [note] David Twede, statement during open mike session, Ex-Mormon Foundation Conference, Salt Lake City, October 19, 2012.