FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Array
Book of Mormon/Synagogues: Difference between revisions
mNo edit summary |
mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Criticism== | ==Criticism== | ||
Critics claim that the | The Book of Mormon mentions "synagogues" twenty five times. Critics claim that "synagogues" were not present among the Jews until ''after'' the Babylonian captivity, and thus Lehi and his family cannot have known of them. The critics insist, therefore, that Book of Mormon use of synagogues is anachronistic. | ||
===Source(s) of the Criticism=== | ===Source(s) of the Criticism=== | ||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
==Response== | ==Response== | ||
The critics' claim that no synagogues were present before the Babylonian captivity is based on out-of-date information: | |||
:I. Levine, a leading scholar on the history of the synagogue, has suggested that synagogues did exist before the Babylonian captivity in the form of chambers in the city gates. Such gates have been excavated by archaeologists at such important Old Testament sites as Beersheba, Gezer, Lachish, and Megiddo. Each of these has | |||
:#at least one chamber (which is nearly square) lined with stone benches around the interior walls (the benched chamber at Lachish has two tiers of benches), | |||
:#a single doorway, and | |||
:#where there is enough of the original wall left to determine it, a niche. I suggest that these niches were used for storing special ritual items, perhaps even sacred scrolls. | |||
:Levine concludes that since later synagogues closely mirror the architecture of the gate chambers, these chambers may well have been the original synagogues. This conclusion is supported by a number of biblical passages that indicate that the city gate and its vicinity were the hub of a community's life. The gate area served as | |||
:#the market place (see {{B|2|Kings|7|1}}), | |||
:#the general court (see {{b||Genesis|23|10,18}}; {{b||Deuteronomy|17|5}}, {{b||Deuteronomy|21|19}} and {{b||Deuteronomy|22|24}}; {{b||Ruth|4|1–12}}; {{b||Jeremiah|38|7}}; {{b||Daniel|2|48–49}}; and {{b||Esther|5|9,13}}; {{b||Esther|6|10}}), | |||
:#the royal court (see {{b|2|Samuel|18|4}} and {{b|2|Samuel|19|8}}; and {{b|1|Kings|22|10}}, which equals {{b|2|Chronicles|18|9}}), and | |||
:#a place of worship (see {{b|2|Kings|23|8}} and {{b||Nehemiah|8|1}}). | |||
:Support for Levine's conclusion is also found in the Old Testament terminology for worship service. Several Old Testament writers (see Hosea 2:11; Jeremiah in Lamentations 2:6; Ezekiel 44:24) link Sabbath worship with the Hebrew word mo‘ed which means "assembly, meeting." | |||
:If Levine is correct, then, before the captivity, a town's or city's social activities centered around the city gate, and it seems reasonable that these social activities included Sabbath worship in a chamber of the gate that resembled later synagogues and functioned similarly.{{ref|fn1}} | |||
==Conclusion== | ==Conclusion== | ||
Assemblies for Jewish worship were known and used prior to the Babylonian captivity. The term "synagogue" is a translation, and need not be the actual Nephites word for these structures. However, pre-captivity Jews had such sites for communal worship. In any case, nothing prevents Nephites from independently developing the idea of a building for group worship, and Joseph Smith translating such a concept as "synagogue." | |||
==Endnotes== | ==Endnotes== | ||
# | # *{{JBMS-9-1-2}} (references silently omitted; see original for much more detail) <!--Adams, synagogues in BoM--> | ||
==Further reading== | ==Further reading== | ||
| Line 16: | Line 36: | ||
===FAIR wiki articles=== | ===FAIR wiki articles=== | ||
{{Book of Mormon Anachronisms}} | {{Book of Mormon Anachronisms}} | ||
===FAIR web site=== | ===FAIR web site=== | ||
===External links=== | ===External links=== | ||
Revision as of 17:52, 3 January 2009
Criticism
The Book of Mormon mentions "synagogues" twenty five times. Critics claim that "synagogues" were not present among the Jews until after the Babylonian captivity, and thus Lehi and his family cannot have known of them. The critics insist, therefore, that Book of Mormon use of synagogues is anachronistic.
Source(s) of the Criticism
- Richard Abanes, Becoming Gods: A Closer Look at 21st-Century Mormonism (Harvest House Publishers: 2005). 58, 359 n. 50, 51. ( Index of claims )
Response
The critics' claim that no synagogues were present before the Babylonian captivity is based on out-of-date information:
- I. Levine, a leading scholar on the history of the synagogue, has suggested that synagogues did exist before the Babylonian captivity in the form of chambers in the city gates. Such gates have been excavated by archaeologists at such important Old Testament sites as Beersheba, Gezer, Lachish, and Megiddo. Each of these has
- at least one chamber (which is nearly square) lined with stone benches around the interior walls (the benched chamber at Lachish has two tiers of benches),
- a single doorway, and
- where there is enough of the original wall left to determine it, a niche. I suggest that these niches were used for storing special ritual items, perhaps even sacred scrolls.
- Levine concludes that since later synagogues closely mirror the architecture of the gate chambers, these chambers may well have been the original synagogues. This conclusion is supported by a number of biblical passages that indicate that the city gate and its vicinity were the hub of a community's life. The gate area served as
- the market place (see 2 Kings 7:1),
- the general court (see Genesis 23:10,18; Deuteronomy 17:5, Deuteronomy 21:19 and Deuteronomy 22:24; Ruth 4:1–12; Jeremiah 38:7; Daniel 2:48–49; and Esther 5:9,13; Esther 6:10),
- the royal court (see 2 Samuel 18:4 and 2 Samuel 19:8; and 1 Kings 22:10, which equals 2 Chronicles 18:9), and
- a place of worship (see 2 Kings 23:8 and Nehemiah 8:1).
- Support for Levine's conclusion is also found in the Old Testament terminology for worship service. Several Old Testament writers (see Hosea 2:11; Jeremiah in Lamentations 2:6; Ezekiel 44:24) link Sabbath worship with the Hebrew word mo‘ed which means "assembly, meeting."
- If Levine is correct, then, before the captivity, a town's or city's social activities centered around the city gate, and it seems reasonable that these social activities included Sabbath worship in a chamber of the gate that resembled later synagogues and functioned similarly.[1]
Conclusion
Assemblies for Jewish worship were known and used prior to the Babylonian captivity. The term "synagogue" is a translation, and need not be the actual Nephites word for these structures. However, pre-captivity Jews had such sites for communal worship. In any case, nothing prevents Nephites from independently developing the idea of a building for group worship, and Joseph Smith translating such a concept as "synagogue."
Endnotes
- *William J. Adams Jr., "Synagogues in the Book of Mormon," Journal of Book of Mormon Studies 9/1 (2000). [4–13] link (references silently omitted; see original for much more detail)
Further reading
FAIR wiki articles
Book of Mormon/Synagogues
FAIR web site
External links
- William J. Adams Jr., "Synagogues in the Book of Mormon," Journal of Book of Mormon Studies 9/1 (2000). [4–13] link